Goodbye Textbooks! Students Are Embracing the Move to Digital Learning [Infographic]

See on Scoop.itThe Digital Professor

Students can’t live without their devices, so schools should embrace the change.

See on


I don’t care about Apple’s so-called eTextbook “walled garden”

The announcement of Apple’s new foray into the educational textbook market has garnered the usual cries of despair over their so-called walled garden. Oh my, what are schools to do? Gosh, how are we to deal with a proprietary ebook format? Guess what, I don’t care about Apple’s so called walled garden when it comes to the new textbook initiative. Some have decried the fact that adopting an an iBook textbook will lock a K-12 school into a particular format. When schools buy a textbook K-12 schools they often buy sets of textbooks from a particlar publisher so they are in a sense locked into a walled publisher garden. They will use them until the are worn and in some case terribly out of date. The fact is, the new iBook textbooks could reduce book costs, possibly keep them more up to date than print,  and in the process give students a much richer educational experience by having an iPad.

I agree with  Buster Heine from Cult of the Mac observations that Apple’s move will enable people like me to share our expertise with a potentially large audience and maybe make a few bucks at the same time. Am I concerned that it is limited to the iPad? No. Heck, my university is a Microsoft colony that basically pays lip service to us Mac users. I’m willing to create educational products that may only work on particular hardware (at this point) and might not even be used by my students. For me it’s about the creative process and desire to explore new ways to help students learn.

The propriety file format argument is a red herring  that doesn’t hold water in the publishing industry. If they deem it important, textbook publishers have ported their textbooks to multiple formats. Just examine the various platforms that Pearson, McGraw Hill, etc. publish their textbooks in. Unless they’ve been barred from doing so, textbooks from these publishers won’t be exclusive to Apple iBook format.

Tech pundits should really move beyond this old and tired “walled garden” arguement. It really is matter of choice. If you want open, go for it. If you want an Apple experience, adopt it. Pundits, quit trying to demonize one paradigm over the other.

The State of Digital Education Infographic

The State of Digital Education

Created by Knewton and Column Five Media

A next-generation digital book

In this TedTalk Mike Matas demos an amazing new interactive book.

William Rankin, LWF Talk, London 2011

Always inspiring, William Rankin from Abilene Christian University presenting his 2011 Learning Without Frontiers talk “Dispatches from the Frontier: Next-wave mobility and the future of digital books”.


Do Students Really Prefer Print Textbooks?

Disclaimer: I am an eTextbook author and have championed the move to digital textbook publishing.

A recent survey was conducted by the National Association of College Stores (NACS) OnCampus Research division to “cut through the speculation” about “how much students are accessing e-books and on what devices.”  The mainstream media focused on the fact that three quarters of those surveyed indicated that they preferred print books. Preference for print depends on a variety of economic and usability factors. The economics of eBook/eReader is real issue in adoption, but what are the device features and user experience that affects student preference? The survey summary report leaves several unresolved issues leading to questionable interpretations of student preference.

Factors influencing reading and learning experience.

As an educator, I take into account the reading and learning experience when choosing an eBook or print book for my course. A poor reading experience is likely to result in poor learning. The reading experience entails the environmental factors influencing how the user interacts with the book and its content. The learning experience is affected by the pedagogical approach to the content.  The reading experience for digital books also depends on the device used for viewing and the format the book is rendered in. Though eBooks are accessible on small mobile devices like the iPhone, they do not necessarily provide the best eTextbook user experience.

The textbook learning experience goes beyond topical content and writing style. It includes structural elements (e.g., detailed contents, index, focus boxes, special formatting for key terms and concepts) and availability of student self-assessment features. Though print textbooks posses these features, the usability can be enhanced in a digital environment.

Choosing the right physical and in the case of a eBook, digital format is nearly as important as the content itself. The reading and learning experience of eBooks can be affected by their format. eBooks appropriate for college study exist over a spectrum of possibilities. At one end are trade eBooks such as a novel used in a literature course, which may be a pdf file or a slightly more feature-rich (e.g., highlighting, embedded note taking), but a still limited ePub. At the other end is a fully interactive eTexbook built on a propriety publisher interface or application with embedded assessments, access to glossaries, note taking, content sharing, etc.  Kindle books are an example of the former while eBooks created for the Kno or as an app for the iPad is an example of the latter.

Survey results:  eBook and Device Preference

According to the NACS report over 600 students participated in the survey, with the “typical respondent” being an upper class female college student between 18 to 24 years old. Of those surveyed, only 13% had bought an eBook within the last three months. Of those who had bought an eBook, two-thirds bought an electronic / digital textbook for a course and one third specifically for leisure reading.  Nearly three quarters indicated that if given choice, “print textbooks would be their top option.” If only 13% had purchased an eBook in the last three months, this means that 87% had not, and possibly never had the opportunity to own one.

Students were asked about their ebook reading experience compared to a print book. Though the survey indicates the type of device used to read their eBook, e.g., desktop, Netbook, smartphone, tablet, it does not indicate if all respondents had access to the same technology for comparison. The survey reported that “one-third” (the report’s underlining emphasis) of the respondents who had read an eBook felt the experience was somewhat to much better than a print book, 25% were neutral and 29% not as good as a print book.  So, for those who have bought an eBook, only 29% (my emphasis) felt it wasn’t as good an experience as a print book. More importantly, combining those that preferred e-books with those with neutral opinions, nearly 60% would have no problem using them for a course. Of those that preferred print, over half indicated that they “simply preferred print”. As noted above, only 13% had bought and eBook (of what format we don’t know). How would one know if they preferred print if they never had used one? One must draw the conclusion that for those who have had experience with both digital and print, e-books meet or exceed their needs when compared to print books.

There is no presentation of book preference by device use,e.g. those who preferred print over digital if using an iPhone, tablet eReader, or desktop. This information might be useful as the eBook reading experience is likely affected by device features, e.g.,  form factor, mobility, screen size, weight, availability of color. If the only exposure to an eBook has been on a black and white Kindle screen, how could they compare that to an interactive textbook created as an app for the iPad or the very least, one delivered as a full-color, media enabled ePub.

Survey results: Concerns about eBooks

The headline that came out of the report was the if the choice was entirely up to them, 74% would prefer print. The survey reported that cost was the top factor that keeps students considering a digital textbook over print, but the report provided to me does not indicate the percentage. There is no doubt that the price of books, whether print or digital, is an issue for cash-strapped students. Interestingly the report states that  “Additional factors that respondents believe are major issues when considering digital is the inability to sell back the book …” However earlier in the report only 7% of those who prefer print indicated that this was an issue with not preferring digital. But if cost was not an issue, would the response be the same?

Of those who preferred print, over half did so because the simply “preferred print to digital”. Why is it that some simply like a printed book, is it the feel, the portability, device requirement? Several respondents were concerned about not being able to highlight text, embed notes on  page, or lose annotations if the e-Book was erased (which by the way, is equivalent to losing a print book). I have to wonder if all the respondents have at least seen an ePub formatted textbook. Most eBooks, especially textbooks from major publishers like Pearson, McGraw Hill, John Wiley have these features. Would those surveyed answer the same way if they had previous experience with an eTextbook with these features?

Interpreting Preference

To understand student preference for one textbook format over another, more effective comparisons and survey questions need to be asked. For instance, what was the satisfaction level of reading on a tablet versus print, or reading on a laptop versus reading on a tablet. What device did those who didn’t like the experience of reading a digital textbook use? What kind of eBook format was bought? Which eBook file formats did students have experience with? A better understanding of preference for print versus digital may be uncovered if survey respondents had the opportunity to compare a static printed textbook to a dynamic, multimedia enriched textbook.  It might be helpful to break out survey preference data by book type, textbook or trade book. Trade eBooks used in a literature course may not require the same digital features that a science textbook does.

Final thoughts

The survey provides a nice snap shot of current purchase and use of eBook and eReaders by students. Discerning student preference for print over digital books from this particular survey is problematic in my opinion. To adequately address preference, survey respondents need access to a variety of eTextbook formats and devices to compare. A simple analogy is a “taste test” where all make side-by-side comparison to decide on preference.  Unless this is done, it’s “speculation” to draw conclusions about student preference from surveys like this.

References for this post:

Electronic Book and e-Reader Device Report. National Association of College Stores October, 2010. Last visited 11/24/2010

Shared on Twitter this week ….

News and comment shared by The Digital Professor this week.

“BBC News – Does it pay to be a student (from the UK) in America?”

The 10 Biggest Myths About Synchronous Online Teaching:

“Professors Publish Guide to Copyright Issues of Multimedia Projects – Wired Campus-The Chronicle of Higher Education”

“Professor’s iPhone App Gets Users Off the Beaten Path – Wired Campus – The Chronicle of Higher Education”

“Isarithmic History of the Two-Party Vote « David B. Sparks”

“Top Trends of 2010: Growth of eBooks & eReaders”

“Paper or electronic? Universities consider e-textbooks | The Daily Collegian”

“E-Learning Brings University Education to Post-Quake Haiti”

%d bloggers like this: